By Rubén Darío Basay Roberts: Chile
Three international investigations challenge the promise of cheaper airport shopping. Chocolates, perfumes and gifts can cost considerably more than in traditional stores. Where is the saving, and what can we do to restore the human meaning of giving?
THE PARADOX OF SHOPPING TAX-FREE
A traveller lands after crossing half the planet. They carry a suitcase, memories and the desire to bring a small gift to the people waiting for them.
Before boarding, they find a Duty Free shop. Perfumes, chocolates, souvenirs and luxury goods seem to offer an irresistible opportunity: shopping without certain taxes.
But one question arises: does shopping tax-free necessarily mean shopping more cheaply?, Research conducted in Chile, New Zealand and South Africa shows that this is not always the case.
Airport retail offers convenience and exclusive products, but its prices deserve scrutiny. The real surprise may come when travellers discover that the same gift costs less outside the airport.
CHILE: THE STUDY OF 63 PRODUCTS
In March 2024, Chile’s National Economic Prosecutor’s Office (FNE) published an analysis of prices at Duty Free stores at Santiago’s Arturo Merino Benítez Airport.
It compared 63 products in beauty, beverages, food and accessories with equivalent products in shops across the capital.
The result was revealing: 33 products were more expensive at Duty Free, while 30 were cheaper.
The authority concluded that tax exemptions do not guarantee lower prices for consumers. It also found no statistically significant average price difference between the two retail channels. The conclusion is simple: a shop’s name does not guarantee savings.
NEW ZEALAND: THE CHOCOLATE THAT MORE THAN DOUBLED IN PRICE
In January 2020, independent consumer organisation Consumer NZ published a comparison of 40 products sold in Duty Free outlets and traditional stores.
A Toblerone Gold chocolate bar cost NZ$16.50 at Duty Free, while Kmart offered the same product for NZ$8. The difference was 106.25%.
Another example was a Whittaker’s chocolate bar sold for NZ$6.50 at the airport, compared with NZ$3.70 at a supermarket. All nine chocolates examined were cheaper outside Duty Free.
Consumer NZ had previously called for an investigation into these product prices, concerned that consumers might misunderstand the promise of savings.
The companies consulted defended their commercial policies, highlighting promotions and price guarantees. The investigation also found genuine savings on certain technology products and beverages. Not every result was unfavourable.
SOUTH AFRICA: LUXURY GOODS AND SURPRISING PRICE DIFFERENCES
In June 2024, journalist Andrew Thompson published an investigation in Financial Mail into prices at South African airports. A bottle of Veuve Clicquot champagne cost 330 rand more at Duty Free than in conventional stores. For Moët & Chandon Brut Impérial, the difference reached 376 rand.
A large Toblerone cost approximately 277 rand at the airport, more than 100 rand extra compared with traditional retailers. However, some whiskies and perfumes were cheaper.
Tax lawyer Petr Erasmus explained that airport retailers may set higher margins to cover expensive rents and other costs. The responsibility for assessing a price also rests with the buyer. But how many passengers really have time to compare prices before boarding?
TRAVELLERS ALSO QUESTION THE PRICES
An international Kearney study conducted in 2023 among 3,570 consumers found that between 50% and 60% of respondents, depending on the category, did not consider Duty Free prices competitive with other retail alternatives.
The consultancy also examined reviews from twelve major airports. Approximately half of the comments about prices were negative. This does not mean that every airport charges excessive prices. Results vary by country, brand and product. But consumer perceptions show that confidence in automatic savings has weakened.
A GIFT SHOULD NOT BE A PRIVILEGE
Behind these figures lies a human dimension that rarely appears in commercial research. A mother returning home, a student coming back after years away, or a grandfather visiting grandchildren may want to bring a small souvenir.
Taking a gift to another part of the world should be an affordable, accessible and humane option for travellers. Airports could offer more handicrafts, local products, cultural souvenirs and affordable small gifts, accompanied by clear price information. Giving a present should not be confused with spending a fortune.
BOOKS: AN OPPORTUNITY TO BRING PEOPLE TOGETHER
There is also a wonderful opportunity to transform the airport shopping experience: books. A bookshop can become a meeting place for travellers, writers and cultures.
Why not offer works by local authors, children’s literature, poetry and small editions in different languages? Why not organise meetings with writers or showcase books that help visitors understand the country they are visiting?
A book can travel thousands of kilometres and open a conversation that lasts a lifetime. Airports have an extraordinary opportunity to bring literature closer to millions of people.
THE TRUE VALUE OF TRAVEL
Duty Free is not necessarily the most expensive place in the world, but neither does it guarantee the best prices. Research shows that comparing prices is essential. We need transparency, competition and genuinely affordable options. Because travel should be an experience of discovery, culture and human connection.
And when someone crosses the planet carrying a gift, what truly matters is not how much they paid for it, but the affection with which they chose to give it.
REFERENCE SOURCES
Chile’s National Economic Prosecutor’s Office, March 2024:
https://www.fne.gob.cl/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/NC-528-24_FNE_Aporta-antecedentes-Duty-Free.pdf
Consumer NZ, 2020:
https://www.consumer.org.nz/shopping/deals-and-savings/duty-free-value
Financial Mail, June 2024:
https://fm.co.za/news-and-fox/2024-06-13-how-prices-at-sa-airports-duty-free-stack-up/
Kearney, travel retail report, 2023.
Writer, communicator and student of public policy:Chile



